Home

Site Map

Trade
Transport
Sustainable Tourism
Natural Disasters

Economic collateral damage

The Greater Caribbean This Week

Norman Girvan

Last week the "collateral damage" of the Iraq war on the economies of the region began to be evident. American Airlines, the largest single carrier of passengers to the region, is cutting back on its services and may be on the brink of filing for Chapter 11 (bankruptcy) protection. BWIA, LIAT and Air Jamaica are similarly stretched and in need of additional governmental financial assistance. The problems are symptomatic of the economic uncertainty produced by war, especially for regional travel and tourism.

 

In the months leading up to the military action, predictions of its economic impact generally depended on whether one assumed that the conflict would be short and relatively simple, or turn out to be prolonged and complicated. On the immediate eve of the conflict world stock markets registered big increases while oil prices plunged, reflecting early market expectations of a speedy coalition victory.

These were based on widely propagated predictions of capitulation by Iraqi forces, collapse of the Saddam Hussein administration, securing of the Iraqi oil fields and installation of a democratic, pro-western government in Iraq. Restoration and expansion of Iraqi oil production, under western control, would undercut the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries cartel and drive the real price of oil down to pre-1973 levels. All this would lift world stock markets, boost international investment and trade, and lead to rapid and sustained global economic recovery-including tourism, since the world would have been made a safer place.

As the war enters its third week, this scenario is appearing less and less likely. Determined resistance by the Iraqi forces, using a combination of conventional and unconventional methods, raise the prospect of a prolonged conflict with no clear-cut victory. And the long-term repercussions are becoming harder to predict with any degree of confidence.

For instance, a prolonged conflict would add to the financial costs of the military action and could substantially impact the US budget deficit. Among the possible consequences are pressure on the US dollar, higher US interest rates and heightened global economic instability.

Another possible fall-out is on global trade negotiations. Some fear that the political rifts generated by the military action could spill over onto preparations for the up-coming World Trade Organisation Ministerial meeting and indirectly affect the growth of world trade. Others believe that this is unlikely, as all countries have a stake in a successful outcome to the meeting.

A more troubling prospect is the risk of increased terrorism. The rising incidence of civilian casualties and the physical occupation of Iraq by western forces could swell the ranks of potential terrorists beyond Al-Qaeda type fanatics to Arabs and Muslims of moderate persuasion, leading to heightened fears about the safety of air travel.

None of these are hoped-for consequences. But responsible and realistic forward planning requires that they be factored into the political and economic equations.

In the light of this, regionalism in the Greater Caribbean will be put to new and unprecedented tests. The difficulties being experienced by regional airlines, for instance, highlight the urgent necessity for implementing a plan for regional airline integration, or at least cooperation. Such a plan has been mooted for many years, backed by studies showing the tangible benefits from cooperation.

The alternative to such integration/cooperation is for one or more the airlines to go into receivership and out of service. There is also the possibility of foreign acquisition, making the region even more reliant on foreign carriers. Either alternative would have negative implications for regional tourism.

 

Professor Norman Girvan is Secretary General of the Association of Caribbean States. The views expressed are not necessarily the official views of the ACS. Feedback can be sent to mail@acs-aec.org.

March 31, 2003

 

Read previous columns:  

 COLUMNS

DATES

Multilateralism under stress March 24, 2003
In the shadow of war March 15, 2003
Euroregion in a Caribbean Space March 8, 2003
Pan-Caribbean Security System Needed
February 28, 2003
Crime and Caribbean Security (3): Cannabis Connections February 21, 2003

Crime and security (2): The Caribbean Corridors

February 15, 2003
Crime and Human Security in The Caribbean (1) February 7, 2003
Caricom's Mixed Fortunes In 2002 February 1, 2003
Cuba, Dominican Republic and Panama in 2002 January 27, 2003
Central America in 2002: coffee crisis; remittances to the rescue January 19, 2003
Tough Times in The Group of 3 January 10, 2003
The lost half decade in Latin America and the Caribbean January 3, 2003
2002: Crime and corruption top the political agenda December 27, 2002
From Nafta to Cafta December 20, 2002
Ibero-Americans Mull Secretariat December 13, 2002
Cuba, CARICOM Cement Ties December 9, 2002
ACS raises $1.1 Million December 3, 2002
ACS meets in Belize November 22,
Flood, Sweat and Tears November 15, 2002
Can Caribbean Tourism be Reinvented? November 11, 2002
Wilton Park Conference on Cuba November 1, 2002
Caribbean-Central America Trade October 26, 2002
Two Thirds Of Central Americans Favour Regional Integration October 21, 2002
Facilitating OCT Cooperation October 11, 2002
Europe's Remaining Dependencies October 4, 2002
Be Offensive in Services September 27, 2002
Services In The Island Caribbean: Neglect Them At Your Peril September 20, 2002
Caricom's Trade Negotiations: A Daunting Agenda September 13, 2002
Regional Cooperation in the Private Sector August 31, 2002
National Politics, Regional Economics August 23, 2002
Economic Contraction and Fiscal Crisis in the OECS August 16, 2002
South American Summit: A Strategic Opportunity August 9, 2002
Human Development in the Caribbean August 2, 2002
Problems with UNDP Governance Indicators July 26, 2002
Relaunch of Central American Integration July 19, 2002
The Caribbean Sea is special July 12, 2002
CARICOM and the ACS July 5, 2002

Treatment of Small Economies

June 28, 2002

Economic Performance in the Island Caribbean

June 21, 2002

Rum Talk

June 14, 2002
Multidimensional vs. Military Security June 7, 2002
EU-LAC Summit: Side Shows and Hidden Agendas May 27, 2002
US Farm subsidies will impact the Greater Caribbean May 17, 2002

Globalization not just Economics

May 10, 2002

Tourism must be Sustainable

May 2, 2002

Eu-lac Summit: Civil Society involvement

April 26, 2002
The EU and Central America: Conflicting Agendas April 19, 2002
Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean: a Fragmented Partnership April 12, 2002
Early warning for Natural Disasters April 5, 2002
Monterrey Summit: Promises, Promises? March 28, 2002
NAFTA Parity:Certain Restrictions Apply March 22, 2002
Private Sector Mobilises March 15, 2002
The Future is Here March 8, 2002
Humanising the FTAA March 1, 2002
US-Central America Free Trade Talks February 22, 2002
Carnival realising the potential February 12, 2002
Bridging Caricom and Central America February 6, 2002
Special and Differential Treatment and the WTO February 1, 2002
Protecting the Caribbean sea January 24, 2002
Thinking the unthinkable - nuclear shipments January 17, 2002
Caribbean airline cooperation - A $60 million question January 12, 2002
A matter of Freedom January 4, 2002
Towards the greater Caribbean zone of cooperation December 27, 2001
Opec funding and the ACS December 20, 2001
Consolidating the Greater Caribbean December 13, 2001
Meeting in Margarita December 7, 2001
Aids, Anthrax and the WTO November 29, 2001
The Dilemma of the DOHA: New Round or No? November 22, 2001
Rescuing Caribbean Tourism pt. 2 November 15, 2001
Rescuing Caribbean Tourism pt. 1 November 9, 2001
Business Co-operation and Caribbean Trade November 2, 2001
TRACKING THE FTAA October 26, 2001
FTAA: DOES SIZE MATTER?
October 18, 2001
WAR AND RUMOURS OF WAR
October 12, 2001
THE QUIET REVOLUTION:
CIVIL SOCIETY AND GLOBALISATION
October 4, 2001
DEVELOPMENT AS IF EQUITY MATTERED October 11, 2001
TERRORISM, TOURISM AND TRADE September 20, 2001
TOWARDS A COMMON POSITION ON SMALL ECONOMIES IN THE FTAA September 13, 2001
 
 

Association of Caribbean States © 2007
Please send questions/comments/suggestions to:

5-7 Sweet Briar Road, St. Clair, P.O. Box 660, Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago, West Indies
Tel: (868) 622 9575 | Fax: (868) 622 1653
mail@acs-aec.org -- http://www.acs-aec.org