Home

Site Map

Trade
Transport
Sustainable Tourism
Natural Disasters

 

KEEPING THE RIGHT BALANCE

 

The Greater Caribbean This Week

Jasmin Garraway

Since its inception in 1997, the umbrella theme adopted for the Caribbean Conference on Sustainable Tourism has been “Keeping the Right Balance”.

This simplistic statement represents the primary and core objective of Sustainable Tourism Development.

The importance of developing tourism on a sustainable path evolved from the recognition that the tourism industry has the capacity for self-destruction through the deterioration of the very resources upon which it depends.

Because of the diversified nature of the industry, the impacts of tourism span the social-cultural and environmental realms. There is evidence that uncontrolled tourism development has resulted in pollution of beaches and waterways, degradation of habitat, soil erosion, water shortages due to competing use by hotels and other tourist facilities and the breakdown of coastal reefs, to name a few.

Whether policy makers are concerned about developing sustainable tourism in order to diversify the existing tourism products, or are motivated by what impact degradation of the environment can have on tourism demand, the question of how to reconcile the objectives of tourism and environmental protection, in order to facilitate Sustainable Tourism Development must be answered.

Each year the Sustainable Tourism Conference (STC) presents a unique opportunity for meaningful dialogue between Policy Makers, Tourism Planners, the private tourism Sector, civil society and others, on these and related issues affecting Sustainable Tourism Development in the region.

The 7 th STC conference held recently in Tobago was developed as a collaborative effort between the Association of Caribbean States (ACS) and the Caribbean Tourism Organization (CTO). This year’s conference, “Keeping the Right Balance – Sustainable Tourism through Diversity “, featured presentations and panels that deliberated on the development of sustainable tourism products, maintaining biodiversity as a means of sustaining tourism, and balancing revenue generation and conservation.

Alessandra Vanzella-Khouri, a representative of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), presented findings on the Reefs at Risk study and on the Biodiversity of the Caribbean Sea .

In terms of its biodiversity, the Caribbean was described as a major migratory route from North America and one of the four “hot spots” in the world, where 50% of the species are unique to the region. All together the reefs cover some 26,000 kilometres. 11% of the world’s corals are said to be located in the Lesser Antilles and the 2 nd largest barrier reef in the world, spanning 220 kilometres, is located in Belize .

The threats evaluated in the Caribbean were marine based - resulting from coastal development and over fishing, as well as watershed-based sources of sediment and pollution, and while the degree of human pressure on coral reefs varied considerably across the region, the findings were that nearly two-thirds of the Caribbean coral reefs are threatened by human activities.

The study concluded that if “current trends in coral reef degradation continue, coastal communities and national economies are poised to sustain substantial economic losses”.

The value of the reefs in the region has been calculated at an estimated at US$ 50 billion and it is believed that coral degradation could result in 2-5% reduction in revenues by 2015. The estimated loss of net revenues is projected at between US$ 100 million to US$ 300 million per year by2015.

Efforts aimed at mitigating the threats to coral reefs have centred on improved management of marine protected areas in general, and in particular, through sustainable fisheries, holistic/integrated management, and management of wastes.

Some examples in the region of balancing revenue generation and conservation through marine protected areas are the Bonaire Marine Park , which, by introducing an annual admission fee of $10 for divers, became self-financing in 1992; the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary generates $18.3 million in annual user value.

These cases demonstrate that tourism can support conservation, provide essential funding, minimise visitor impacts and enhance protection of reefs. Moreover they refute the belief of authors such as Bob Mc Kercher who in his thesis “Fundamental Truths about Tourism” suggests that “Sustainable tourism is a myth to be pursued but never attained.”

 

 

 

Ms. Jasmin Garraway is the Sustainable Tourism Director of the Association of Caribbean States. The views expressed are not necessarily the official views of the ACS. Feedback can be sent to mail@acs-aec.org

10 May, 2005


 

 

 

 

Read previous columns:  

 COLUMNS

DATES

PRAISES FOR CARIBBEAN ART DURING THE TEN YEARS OF THE ACS

03 May, 2005
HAITI VISITED BY PEACE 20 April, 2005
NO INTEGRATION A LA CARTE 05 April, 2005
THE CARIBBEAN THEY LEFT US IS NOT THE ONE WE WANT 29 March, 2005
THE CHALLENGE OF CUSTOMS MODERNISATION AND FACILITATION 22 March, 2005
TRANSPORT IN THE GREATER CARIBBEAN 15 March, 2005
REGIONAL LEADERSHIP MAKES INTEGRATION POSSIBLE 08 March, 2005
MULTILATERALISM AND REGIONALISM IN THE 21 ST CENTURY: MAXIMISING POTENTIALS 02 March, 2005
GOVERNANCE, INTEGRATION AND SECURITY 23 February, 2005
ANNOUNCING A GREAT CATASTROPHE 15 February, 2005
INTEGRATION AND PEACE. CARIBBEAN GOALS 09 February, 2005
EXPLORING TOURIST PROTECTION 01 February, 2005
THE NEW GEOGRAPHY OF WORLD TRADE 25 January, 2005
A NEW INSTRUMENT FOR REGIONAL CO-OPERATION 17 January, 2005

THE UNCERTAINTY AND RISKS OF THE FUTURE

11 January, 2005
THE POOR SUSIDISE DEVELOPMENT 01 December, 2004
CREATION OF THE SUSTAINABLE TOURISM PROGRAMME INTEGRATION OF THE GREATER CARIBBEAN 23 November, 2004
THE RIO GROUP - A HISTORICE DATE WITH INTEGRATION 12 November, 2004
MOVING IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION TO IMPROVE TRADE AMONG THE COUNTRIES OF THE GREATER 09 November, 2004
THE GREATER CARIBBEAN, A SPACE IN
INTERNATIONAL CO-OPERATION
01 November, 2004
October 26, 2004
CHAGUARAMAS: FIRST WORKSHOP HELD ON THE APPLICATION OF TOURISM SUSTAINABILITY INDICATORS IN THE GREATER CARIBBEAN October 19, 2004
THE CARIBBEAN SEA INITIATIVE October 08, 2004
THE GONAIVES PACT October 01, 2004
TOOLS FOR LIFE September 27, 2004
HURRICANES ARE NATURAL AND DISASTERS ARE MAN-MADE September 20, 2004
G-3 IN THE GREATER CARIBBEAN September 13, 2004
E-COMMERCE AND BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES FOR SMALL AND MEDIUM ENTERPRISES September 06, 2004
SUSTAINABILITY IN THE GREATER CARIBBEAN September 01, 2004
SUSTAINABLE TOURISM – A CALL FOR ACTION Aug 24, 2004
BUSINESS FORUMS: INSTRUMENT AIMED AT FACILITATING TRADE EXPANSION AMONG THE COUNTRIES OF THE CARIBBEAN Aug 11, 2004
ACS - PAST, PRESENT, FUTURE Aug 04, 2004
Bilateralism and Integration - The New Wave in World Trade July 14, 2004
Toward The Analysis of The Sustainable Touristic Destination of The Greater Caribbean June 18, 2004
The Latin American And Caribbean / European Union Summit: Multilateralism And Regionalism June 1, 2004
Caribbean Tourism Ministers Support Sustainability May 17, 2004
The Imminence of Intra-Caribbean Trade April 20, 2004
Tourism in the Greater Caribbean: Towards the Implementation of a Sustainable Tourism Zone April 13, 2004
Multilateralism and the ACS April 7, 2004
March 17, 2004
Historical Roots of the Haitian Crisis March 10, 2004
CAFTA: A Grey Area for Central America March 3, 2004
Four Challenging Years February 20, 2004
ACS Agreements Signed February 18, 2004
CAFTA: The Other Side of the Coin February 10, 2004
January 27, 2004
The Sustainable Tourism Zone of the Caribbean: Advances January 16, 2004
ACS Ministers Ponder Progress December 5, 2003
Mother Nature is not to be blamed November 27, 2003
Fast changing trade environment November 21, 2003
The Iberoamerican Summit and Multilateralism November 17, 2003
Caribbean Connections November 11, 2003
A Virtual Market for the Greater Caribbean November 3, 2003
Obstacles to Trade in the Greater Caribbean October 27, 2003
SIDS and Regional Cooperation in the Greater Caribbean October 17, 2003
TNC MEETING-A TALE OF TWO FTAAs October 10, 2003
Natural Barriers to Sustainable Development October 7, 2003
EXPECTATIONS CONFIRMED IN CANCUN October 2, 2003
REGIONAL CONFERENCE ON TOURIST SAFETY September 23, 2003
From Doha to Cancun September 16, 2003
PROTECTING HOMES AND HUMAN LIVES September 10, 2003

August 27, 2003

Trade negotiations and labour standards August 20, 2003
Wanted: Regional Tourism Security Network August 13, 2003
In Unity there is Strength August 6, 2003
Keeping the Right Balance July 30, 2003
Negotiating sustainable tourism July 23, 2003
ACS OKAYS TRANSPORT AGREEMENT July 14, 2003
ASSESSING THE CARICOM SUMMIT July 8, 2003
CARICOM’S GOVERNANCE: NO TIME FOR INACTION June 30, 2003
A NEW TWIST TO DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT June 21, 2003
Adding Value to the Region June 18, 2003
Should BWIA and LIAT Merge? June 6, 2003
TRADE AND HUMAN DEVELOPMENT June 1, 2003
Making global trade work for people May 26, 2003
CAFTA: DISPUTE RESOLUTION, LABOUR AND THE ENVIRONMENT May 17, 2003
Convergence and Divergence in CAFTA May 12, 2003
UPDATE ON CAFTA May 5, 2003
Social Cohesion and the FTAA April 26, 2003
Missed deadlines April 19, 2003
Airline Integration: Biting the Bullet April 12, 2003
Regional Airlines in Crisis April 5, 2003
Economic collateral damage March 31, 2003
Multilateralism under stress March 24, 2003
In the shadow of war March 15, 2003
Euroregion in a Caribbean Space March 8, 2003
Pan-Caribbean Security System Needed
February 28, 2003
Crime and Caribbean Security (3): Cannabis Connections February 21, 2003

Crime and security (2): The Caribbean Corridors

February 15, 2003
Crime and Human Security in The Caribbean (1) February 7, 2003
Caricom's Mixed Fortunes In 2002 February 1, 2003
Cuba, Dominican Republic and Panama in 2002 January 27, 2003
Central America in 2002: coffee crisis; remittances to the rescue January 19, 2003
Tough Times in The Group of 3 January 10, 2003
The lost half decade in Latin America and the Caribbean January 3, 2003
2002: Crime and corruption top the political agenda December 27, 2002
From Nafta to Cafta December 20, 2002
Ibero-Americans Mull Secretariat December 13, 2002
Cuba, CARICOM Cement Ties December 9, 2002
ACS raises $1.1 Million December 3, 2002
ACS meets in Belize November 22,
Flood, Sweat and Tears November 15, 2002
Can Caribbean Tourism be Reinvented? November 11, 2002
Wilton Park Conference on Cuba November 1, 2002
Caribbean-Central America Trade October 26, 2002
Two Thirds Of Central Americans Favour Regional Integration October 21, 2002
Facilitating OCT Cooperation October 11, 2002
Europe's Remaining Dependencies October 4, 2002
Be Offensive in Services September 27, 2002
Services In The Island Caribbean: Neglect Them At Your Peril September 20, 2002
Caricom's Trade Negotiations: A Daunting Agenda September 13, 2002
Regional Cooperation in the Private Sector August 31, 2002
National Politics, Regional Economics August 23, 2002
Economic Contraction and Fiscal Crisis in the OECS August 16, 2002
South American Summit: A Strategic Opportunity August 9, 2002
Human Development in the Caribbean August 2, 2002
Problems with UNDP Governance Indicators July 26, 2002
Relaunch of Central American Integration July 19, 2002
The Caribbean Sea is special July 12, 2002
CARICOM and the ACS July 5, 2002

Treatment of Small Economies

June 28, 2002

Economic Performance in the Island Caribbean

June 21, 2002

Rum Talk

June 14, 2002
Multidimensional vs. Military Security June 7, 2002
EU-LAC Summit: Side Shows and Hidden Agendas May 27, 2002
US Farm subsidies will impact the Greater Caribbean May 17, 2002

Globalization not just Economics

May 10, 2002

Tourism must be Sustainable

May 2, 2002

Eu-lac Summit: Civil Society involvement

April 26, 2002
The EU and Central America: Conflicting Agendas April 19, 2002
Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean: a Fragmented Partnership April 12, 2002
Early warning for Natural Disasters April 5, 2002
Monterrey Summit: Promises, Promises? March 28, 2002
NAFTA Parity:Certain Restrictions Apply March 22, 2002
Private Sector Mobilises March 15, 2002
The Future is Here March 8, 2002
Humanising the FTAA March 1, 2002
US-Central America Free Trade Talks February 22, 2002
Carnival realising the potential February 12, 2002
Bridging Caricom and Central America February 6, 2002
Special and Differential Treatment and the WTO February 1, 2002
Protecting the Caribbean sea January 24, 2002
Thinking the unthinkable - nuclear shipments January 17, 2002
Caribbean airline cooperation - A $60 million question January 12, 2002
A matter of Freedom January 4, 2002
Towards the greater Caribbean zone of cooperation December 27, 2001
Opec funding and the ACS December 20, 2001
Consolidating the Greater Caribbean December 13, 2001
Meeting in Margarita December 7, 2001
Aids, Anthrax and the WTO November 29, 2001
The Dilemma of the DOHA: New Round or No? November 22, 2001
Rescuing Caribbean Tourism pt. 2 November 15, 2001
Rescuing Caribbean Tourism pt. 1 November 9, 2001
Business Co-operation and Caribbean Trade November 2, 2001
TRACKING THE FTAA October 26, 2001
FTAA: DOES SIZE MATTER?
October 18, 2001
WAR AND RUMOURS OF WAR
October 12, 2001
THE QUIET REVOLUTION:
CIVIL SOCIETY AND GLOBALISATION
October 4, 2001
DEVELOPMENT AS IF EQUITY MATTERED October 11, 2001
TERRORISM, TOURISM AND TRADE September 20, 2001
TOWARDS A COMMON POSITION ON SMALL ECONOMIES IN THE FTAA September 13, 2001
 


 
   

Association of Caribbean States © 2007
Please send questions/comments/suggestions to:

5-7 Sweet Briar Road, St. Clair, P.O. Box 660, Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago, West Indies
Tel: (868) 622 9575 | Fax: (868) 622 1653
mail@acs-aec.org -- http://www.acs-aec.org